Western PhilosophyStuff Happened · Philosophy
An oil portrait of a seated older man in a dark coat, hair grey at the temples, looking out with a composed, heavy-lidded gaze
School

German Idealists

1781 – 1831 · 3 thinkers

Kant had bought peace between science and religion at a strange price: he split the world in two. There is the world as the mind structures it, which we can know with certainty, and there is the world as it is in itself, which we can never reach at all. For roughly sixty years a chain of brilliant Germans found that unreachable half intolerable and tried, each in turn, to close the gap. Fichte threw the unknowable thing out and grounded everything in the free, active self. Schelling made nature and mind two faces of one Absolute. Hegel made the Absolute a Spirit that develops through all of history toward knowing itself, with nothing left over and nothing unknowable beyond it. It was the most ambitious construction in the history of philosophy, and when it cracked it cracked spectacularly: into Marx, who kept the engine and threw out the Spirit, into Kierkegaard, who said no system could ever hold a single living person, and into a long backlash that treated the whole edifice as a cautionary tale. This is the story of the tradition as one connected arc, the handoffs from mind to mind.

The core claim
Before
Kant's critical dualism: knowable appearances structured by fixed mental categories, walled off forever from an unknowable thing-in-itself
After
A single self-developing Absolute or Spirit, unfolding through history, with nothing unknowable left beyond it
The whole German Idealists storyThe tradition across the centuries, in the house voice
Inside the read
The thread Kant left hanging
Fichte takes down the wall
Schelling puts nature back
Hegel makes the Absolute move
The system splits in two
The long afterlife
The thinkers
Kant
1724 – 1804
The mind builds the world it experiences; the categorical imperative.
Read
Fichte
1762 – 1814
The self posits itself, and the world along with it.
Read
Hegel
1770 – 1831
Spirit unfolds through history by thesis meeting its negation.
Read