Western PhilosophyStuff Happened · Philosophy
A pencil sketch of a young man with thick wavy hair swept up from a high forehead, in a dark coat with a high collar, looking off to one side
School

Existentialists

1843 – · 1 thinkers

Philosophy had spent two thousand years asking what things essentially are: what is justice, what is the good, what is a human being in general. By the middle of the nineteenth century that question had been answered as completely as it ever would be, in Hegel's vast System that fit all of reality, history, and humanity into one developing rational whole. And then a few writers noticed that the System, for all its completeness, had no room for the one thing each of them actually was: a particular person, alive now, afraid, having to choose, with no proof to lean on and no second life to get it right in. A Danish religious writer, a German philosopher with a hammer, and a Russian novelist of the cellar each, separately, turned philosophy around to start from there, from the concrete existing individual rather than the universal essence. None of them used the word existentialism; the word and the organized movement came later, in the twentieth century, when Heidegger, Sartre, Camus, and de Beauvoir built a whole philosophy on the ground these three had broken. This is the story of that ground: the stuck question they all answered, the answers themselves, and the shared preoccupation, with existence, freedom, anxiety, and meaning in a universe that no longer hands them over, that holds the otherwise wildly different thinkers together under one retrospective name.

The core claim
Before
Philosophy's job is to build systems about essences and universals: to say what justice is, what the good is, what a human being is in general, and to fit it all into one rational order that holds for everyone, everywhere, regardless of who is asking
After
Philosophy must start from the concrete existing individual: this particular person, alive now, free, anxious, having to choose and to stake a life without proof, the one thing no system of universals can ever contain
The whole Existentialists storyThe tradition across the centuries, in the house voice
Inside the read
The stuck question
Kierkegaard's move
Nietzsche's parallel move
The voice from the cellar
What they shared
Where the story goes next
The thinkers
Kierkegaard
1813 – 1855
Truth is subjectivity; faith is a leap over the edge of reason.
Read